anyone else happy the JETS didn't get the chance to take McFadden

**starbuck** · April 12th, 2009, 04:56 PM

Originally Posted by starbuck

I think McFadden will be another Reggie Bush, good solid NFL player but nothing special

Year one and my statement looks good. lets see what will happen in year 2. I might eat my words but I still don't think he will be a "special" back.

**Biggin** · April 12th, 2009, 10:02 PM

his toe held him back last season, but i still believe he will be a pro bowler one day, hes the shit, too much talent not to be great.

**duckmeat** · April 16th, 2009, 01:42 AM

Originally Posted by starbuck

Year one and my statement looks good. lets see what will happen in year 2. I might eat my words but I still don't think he will be a "special" back.

Gilbert Godfried would have been a better pick than Gholston, another of those workout warriors taken way too high. Mcfadden hands down would have been a better pick even though he wasn't there.

I don't think he is even comparable to Reggie Bush. Plays with alot more power, and ran through the SEC instead of the Pac-10. Also wasn't playing for a powerhouse in a system that makes all of its players look great. I knew Bush wouldn't be shit coming out of college into the NFL, but I was real high on Mcfadden and still think he is one of the best backs to come out in awhile. Bush also went to a strong offensive team with a proven QB and and good bruising RB to spell him, and still hasn't done anything. Mcfadden went to the Raiders, was injured, and they had a terrible year with a team that had alot of holes. He'll go for 1450 yards this year. Write it down.